Stock Groups

Investors warn European companies over climate accounting -Breaking


© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: A girl walks throughout a bridge in entrance of a chimney billowing smoke from a coal-burning energy station in central Beijing February 25, 2011. REUTERS/David Grey/File Picture


By Simon Jessop

LONDON (Reuters) – Thirty-four traders managing greater than $7 trillion in property have warned 17 of Europe’s largest corporations, together with BP (NYSE:) and Volkswagen (DE:), that they may problem board administrators over their accounting of local weather dangers.

The transfer is the most recent push by traders to strain corporations and their auditors, charging them with not shifting quick sufficient to adapt to the world’s transition to a low-carbon economic system or being clear sufficient in regards to the potential impacts.

In letters despatched between December and February and seen by Reuters, the traders instructed the businesses their accounts didn’t mirror the fallout from local weather change on their property and liabilities. For instance, some property could depreciate quicker in worth whereas demand for sure merchandise could fall.

The necessity for quicker motion to cap world warming at 1.5 levels Celsius and mitigate its worst extremes was reiterated by U.N. local weather scientists in a landmark report on Monday.

“Traders can not perceive the true worth of an organization with out realizing the embedded local weather dangers,” Natasha Landell-Mills, accomplice and head of stewardship at funding supervisor Sarasin & Companions, one of many signatories to the letters, stated in an interview.

Others to signal embody the fund arm of HSBC, French public pension scheme ERAFP, and BMO International Asset Administration EMEA, a part of U.S. asset supervisor Columbia Threadneedle.

Traders have tried to press the businesses on the problem earlier than. In 2020, by means of the Institutional Traders Group on Local weather Change, they laid out a sequence of steps boards wanted to take to align their accounts with the Paris Settlement on local weather, together with altering key accounting assumptions.

The traders discovered that almost all corporations did not adequately reply, prompting the most recent string of letters warning boards they confronted opposition at their upcoming annual common assembly.

“From subsequent voting season you need to more and more anticipate to see traders vote towards Audit Committee administrators’ reappointment, the place high-risk corporations fail to satisfy the expectations,” the letters stated.

Shareholder votes is also forged towards corporations’ choice to retain their auditors or a request to approve their monetary statements, Landell-Mills stated.


Air Liquide (OTC:), Anglo American (LON:), Arcelor Mittal, BMW, Daimler (OTC:), Enel (MI:), Equinor, Glencore (OTC:), Rio Tinto (NYSE:), Saint-Gobain, Shell (LON:), Renault (PA:), CRH (NYSE:), ThyssenKrupp and TotalEnergies additionally acquired letters.

The letters had been copied to the businesses’ lead audit companions. Individually, the traders additionally contacted the most important accountants in Britain, america and France over the problem.

Landell-Mills stated votes can be influenced by the most recent annual stories, and that Sarasin had determined to vote towards the monetary assertion and auditor at Rio Tinto’s AGM, and abstain on whether or not to reelect the Audit Committee’s chair.

She added she was happy to see Shell embody a ‘sensitivity evaluation’ within the notes to its accounts, launched after the letter had been despatched, that confirmed impairments might hit $27-$33 billion primarily based on common costs from 4 1.5-2C local weather change situations. Landell-Mills stated she nonetheless wished to know what a pure 1.5C situation would imply for impairments.

Air Liquide and Saint Gobain (PA:) each stated they had been liaising with the IIGCC, a European membership physique for traders collaborating on local weather change, and that local weather dangers had been factored into their accounts. Anglo American stated it was partaking with IIGCC.

Mercedes Benz, previously Daimler, stated it was in “fixed and constructive” dialogue with the traders and would replace its sustainability technique on April 11. Equinor referred to its vitality transition plan as being on a Paris-aligned pathway.

Enel stated it will not touch upon talks with shareholders. Glencore declined to touch upon the letter, however its 2021 annual report accommodates a sensitivity evaluation.

ThyssenKrupp shared a letter despatched in reply to IIGCC member Rathbones Funding Administration by which it stated it understood traders’ want for extra detailed info and was “presently inspecting how we could implement your inquiry”.

The remainder of the businesses didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Whereas many corporations have pledged to get to net-zero emissions and are beneath rising strain from regulators to reveal their efforts, the bulk have but to align their enterprise practices, together with their accounts, with the purpose, the traders say.

“We are able to’t depend on ‘enterprise as regular’ accounting assumptions because the vitality transition unfolds. Together with our dedication to be a internet zero investor, guaranteeing firm accounts are aligned to a 1.5°C diploma future is a vital first step,” stated Matt Crossman, stewardship director at Rathbones.